It looks like and sounds like I got some small holes in the muffler.
This is a 1992 2wd pickup with the 22re.

I want a quiet muffler and looking for some advice.

Right now i'm thinking I'll only need to replace from the cat converter back.

 

Take it to a local exhaust shop. They have OE type replacements.

 

I threw a glass pack on mine, expecting it to be loud, but its actually really quiet. I was quite surprised! Then again, I am sure if I take the cat off it will be louder. Since you still have the cat on, I would think it would be quiet for you too.

 

I was hoping to order something online
I don't really want to bring it to a shop.

 

look at napa or oreillys online they have stock replacements for cheap

 

^^ this
just remember that stock is quiet, and anything smaller will be louder (and vis-versa)

 

Cherry bomb glasspacks actually sound pretty good, and not obnxious or loud as along as you keep the cat on. My buddy has one of his 85'.

 

I currently have a Thrush Turbo on the 94 which is not as quiet as a stocker but not as bad as a full flow such as a Flow Master. It makes a little rumble at the upper RPM's but nothing too loud. But I also have no cat as that's the way I bought it. I first tried a Thrush welded which is essentially a FlowMaster but cheaper, but with no cat or resonator it screamed like a angry crotch rocket. Way too annoying but I'm 46 not 26. If you want quiet, stick with an OEM style muffler.