Famous "high idle/surge" culprits!
#223
LOL...true
Anyway, the idle still changes all the time. Not sure if a thermostat has a darn thing to do with it but its bugging me...lol. When I get off of the free way the idle goes up and will surge a little. When I'm in town the idle is about 800-600rpm. When/if I hot rod it it goes even lower. So, whats up??
Anyway, the idle still changes all the time. Not sure if a thermostat has a darn thing to do with it but its bugging me...lol. When I get off of the free way the idle goes up and will surge a little. When I'm in town the idle is about 800-600rpm. When/if I hot rod it it goes even lower. So, whats up??
#227
Registered User
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 8,656
Likes: 16
From: NW Ark on wooded ten acres...Ozarks at large!
You've got to be kidding me! You're saying the air filter's been this big problem all along?! How long had it been since you've changed it?
Ugh...internet mechanics. One might as well be workin' blind folded....
Ugh...internet mechanics. One might as well be workin' blind folded....
#230
No you fools
It fixed a weird power issue (while driving and trying to go fast) I never said anything about it since I thought it was the crappy cylinder.
Anyway, I've still got the idle problem though. If it can't be fixed because of my compression...then so be it. But it worked fine before the tear down...lol.
The idle is a little rough at 600rpm. It feels "alright" at 800. It still shakes a little.
So, what do you think with my changing idle all the time?
It fixed a weird power issue (while driving and trying to go fast) I never said anything about it since I thought it was the crappy cylinder.
Anyway, I've still got the idle problem though. If it can't be fixed because of my compression...then so be it. But it worked fine before the tear down...lol.
The idle is a little rough at 600rpm. It feels "alright" at 800. It still shakes a little.
So, what do you think with my changing idle all the time?
#233
I'm NOT going to get out of my truck and adjust the idle every time it changes...that is just rediculous
#234
well here's a suggestion- let's get a consistant idle speed, irregardless of what it is, let's get a consistant speed- something stable to work from.
I don't care if it's 2000 rpm or whatever... just one idle speed that doesn't change more than 100 rpm no matter what.
We'll work from there.

Once we're stable somewhere, we'll work on bringing it down where it should be.
Trust me, I'm as tired of this as you are... maybe actually even more so. I hate being beaten.
I don't care if it's 2000 rpm or whatever... just one idle speed that doesn't change more than 100 rpm no matter what.
We'll work from there.

Once we're stable somewhere, we'll work on bringing it down where it should be.
Trust me, I'm as tired of this as you are... maybe actually even more so. I hate being beaten.
Last edited by abecedarian; May 20, 2008 at 08:03 PM.
#235
well here's a suggestion- let's get a consistant idle speed, irregardless of what it is, let's get a consistant speed- something stable to work from.
I don't care if it's 2000 rpm or whatever... just one idle speed that doesn't change more than 100 rpm no matter what.
We'll work from there.

Once we're stable somewhere, we'll work on bringing it down where it should be.
Trust me, I'm as tired of this as you are... maybe actually even more so. I hate being beaten.
I don't care if it's 2000 rpm or whatever... just one idle speed that doesn't change more than 100 rpm no matter what.
We'll work from there.

Once we're stable somewhere, we'll work on bringing it down where it should be.
Trust me, I'm as tired of this as you are... maybe actually even more so. I hate being beaten.
Are you sure this has nothing to do with the stupid thermostat?
#236
Quite possibly could be the thermostat not operating properly. But that's hard to say absolutely, without doubt. After all, if the coolant does warm up properly and does not overheat, it would seem that the thermostat is working.
What is the temperature rating on the t-stat?
Do you know anyone with an infrared thermometer? It might be an interesting adventure to shoot the cylinder head temperatures by each spark plug while it's running and at different times to see if the head is generating abnormally, localized (by the cylinder) high temps and is affecting how the engine runs.
What is the temperature rating on the t-stat?
Do you know anyone with an infrared thermometer? It might be an interesting adventure to shoot the cylinder head temperatures by each spark plug while it's running and at different times to see if the head is generating abnormally, localized (by the cylinder) high temps and is affecting how the engine runs.
#237
Quite possibly could be the thermostat not operating properly. But that's hard to say absolutely, without doubt. After all, if the coolant does warm up properly and does not overheat, it would seem that the thermostat is working.
What is the temperature rating on the t-stat?
Do you know anyone with an infrared thermometer? It might be an interesting adventure to shoot the cylinder head temperatures by each spark plug while it's running and at different times to see if the head is generating abnormally, localized (by the cylinder) high temps and is affecting how the engine runs.
What is the temperature rating on the t-stat?
Do you know anyone with an infrared thermometer? It might be an interesting adventure to shoot the cylinder head temperatures by each spark plug while it's running and at different times to see if the head is generating abnormally, localized (by the cylinder) high temps and is affecting how the engine runs.
I have an infrared thermometer and used it to verify that it was over-heating.
So, your saying that the "good" pistons could be cooler or hotter than the #3 piston and that could cause the idle to go ballistic? Something along those lines though.
#238
Well, now that you mention it, yeah, that's what I was thinking- that the weak cylinder is in some way affecting the cylinder head temperatures to the detriment of the engine performance. (I think I mentioned that idea somewhere else in this thread, but I'm too lazy to go back and find it.
)
But never-the-less... cylinder head temps WILL affect engine performance. A hot engine that has not yet blown the head gasket will run noticebly better, smoother even, than a cooler / normal stock-temp head.
And the cooling system CAN mask cylinder head temp variations quite easily.
)But never-the-less... cylinder head temps WILL affect engine performance. A hot engine that has not yet blown the head gasket will run noticebly better, smoother even, than a cooler / normal stock-temp head.
And the cooling system CAN mask cylinder head temp variations quite easily.
#239
Are 22re's supposed to be this ty? I probably would have had better luck with an american pos. I can't believe my brothers has lasted 250k miles. The last 100k miles have been "untouched" and it still purrs. Why do I ALWAYS get stuck with a pile of . For some reason I can't blow it up? Any tips? Apparently holding my foot to the floor for 30 seconds won't.
I'll be back...hopefully with a different attitude
I'll be back...hopefully with a different attitude
#240
Hold your foot to the floor for 30 seconds with an 'american pos' and tell me what happens.
Ultimately, a used car is subjected the the whims and fancies of the current and previous owner(s). Some people take care care of theirs and others don't.
Just because yours is causing problems does not mean it's a design deficiency or something of the like.
Given you replaced the head gasket and still have a compression problem, I may be more inclined to blame you for not fixing a problem (that could've been fixed when the engine was apart) than I would be to blame someone for blowing the gasket up in the first place.
*edit- sorry if I come across all agro and emo. It's just harder to fix a problem when something else is wrong.
Ultimately, a used car is subjected the the whims and fancies of the current and previous owner(s). Some people take care care of theirs and others don't.
Just because yours is causing problems does not mean it's a design deficiency or something of the like.
Given you replaced the head gasket and still have a compression problem, I may be more inclined to blame you for not fixing a problem (that could've been fixed when the engine was apart) than I would be to blame someone for blowing the gasket up in the first place.
*edit- sorry if I come across all agro and emo. It's just harder to fix a problem when something else is wrong.
Last edited by abecedarian; May 21, 2008 at 05:29 PM.


