Is it just me?!! Toyota Reliability/reputation
#1
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: central new york state (DeRuyter)
I finnally land an 86 yota in good shape, a year and a half ago. I always wanted one. I'm not so sure anymore... 
So, i thought that these yota trucks were supposed to have the best, most reliable motors in them. But I hear about too many head gaskets...
I replaced the radiator this fall with a proper flush and new fluid. The rad level kept going down. I thought it was just some air in the heater core. Finally topped off I think but fluid going down. Now i have some pressure in the coolant system when stone cold. My oil level is rising and the radiator fluid is going (you guessed it) where it does not belong!! I have not confirmed its in the oil pan yet but there is some moisture (chocolate crud) under the oil cap.
It apperas this motor already had a new head on it by PO. So what gives?! Whats with the #[%^[+ head gaskets?!
How often do these motors have to be rebuilt? Even a new head gasket is not what i need to be doing w/ a newborn and no shop or extra vehicle. I need to get to work...
Just bummed

So, i thought that these yota trucks were supposed to have the best, most reliable motors in them. But I hear about too many head gaskets...
I replaced the radiator this fall with a proper flush and new fluid. The rad level kept going down. I thought it was just some air in the heater core. Finally topped off I think but fluid going down. Now i have some pressure in the coolant system when stone cold. My oil level is rising and the radiator fluid is going (you guessed it) where it does not belong!! I have not confirmed its in the oil pan yet but there is some moisture (chocolate crud) under the oil cap.
It apperas this motor already had a new head on it by PO. So what gives?! Whats with the #[%^[+ head gaskets?!
How often do these motors have to be rebuilt? Even a new head gasket is not what i need to be doing w/ a newborn and no shop or extra vehicle. I need to get to work...

Just bummed
#4
So your upset that a 23 year old truck needs some work?? And your surprised that somebody else did a bad job at fixing something cheaply?? Im not trying to bash you just give you some reality..... These motors get 300,000 plus miles but it depends how hard a life they have had.
#5
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: central new york state (DeRuyter)
If so reliable then why does the head gasket go? My truck has only 95k on it. So when did the PO head gasket go, for him to then replace it with non OEM. Certainly less than 95k, right?
I hear the '96 nissan trucks go for over 200k no probs w/ motor
I hear the '96 nissan trucks go for over 200k no probs w/ motor
#6
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: central new york state (DeRuyter)
So your upset that a 23 year old truck needs some work?? And your surprised that somebody else did a bad job at fixing something cheaply?? Im not trying to bash you just give you some reality..... These motors get 300,000 plus miles but it depends how hard a life they have had.
Thanks
#7
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: central new york state (DeRuyter)
So what is the best approach?
The way i feel if i replace the head gasket, i may as well do the oil pump, timing chain, water pump and whatever else. Maybe just rebuild or swap the motor with new. That way i know what i got. Also would it be faster to swap out whole motor than to piece together in the engine bay?
Does engine builder sell a new motor? I don't see one on their website.
The way i feel if i replace the head gasket, i may as well do the oil pump, timing chain, water pump and whatever else. Maybe just rebuild or swap the motor with new. That way i know what i got. Also would it be faster to swap out whole motor than to piece together in the engine bay?
Does engine builder sell a new motor? I don't see one on their website.
Trending Topics
#8
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: central new york state (DeRuyter)
If i take something off to get to the HG, im going to take a hard look at everything and just replace. But how is my foundation? Block, main??
I could start with a compression test...
I wonder how much time i have...
I could start with a compression test...
I wonder how much time i have...
#9
Go with engnbldr stuff very quality. The fact is many people know the bulletproof reliability legend of the 22re, so they feel they dont have to maintain them. They simply ignore the whole truck. make the truck your own and build it how you want within a budget you can afford. mild to wild, all yotas are fun
#12
Registered User
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2,159
Likes: 7
From: Pleasanton, CA - SF Bay Area
A 22RE is only as reliable as the person who rebuilt it/maintained it....
go to eBay and search ENGNBLDR or go to ENGNBLDR.com and call them.
Get an OEM HG, and get the Front End Kit (timing chain, cover, water & oil pump and gaskets...for like $150). The HG is less than $50 OEM online....toyotapartszone.
do it right. Then complain when it breaks
Tons of guides online....check out user 92 TOY's write up in his signature.
go to eBay and search ENGNBLDR or go to ENGNBLDR.com and call them.
Get an OEM HG, and get the Front End Kit (timing chain, cover, water & oil pump and gaskets...for like $150). The HG is less than $50 OEM online....toyotapartszone.
do it right. Then complain when it breaks

Tons of guides online....check out user 92 TOY's write up in his signature.
#13
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 13,381
Likes: 100
From: I live in New Tripoli Pa out in the woods
You have no idea what could have caused the head gasket failure.
As an example I had a heater hose fail yes it did get a little hot till I could get it off the road. And repair about 2 weeks later I had a head gasket failure.
Then the fact that most people don`t know the little error Toyota had with under torquing the head bolts so a failure down the road is a real good possibility

As an example I had a heater hose fail yes it did get a little hot till I could get it off the road. And repair about 2 weeks later I had a head gasket failure.
Then the fact that most people don`t know the little error Toyota had with under torquing the head bolts so a failure down the road is a real good possibility
#14
how many people have owned the truck ahead of you? How many actually did any up keep?
abuse a truck for 20+ years and it is gonna have issues unless you know the entire history of the truck.
I have had my '81 for 6 years..before that it had 20 owners...you should see some of the crap I have been fixing over the years.
Bullet Proof and uber Reliable reputations are directly related to proper maintenance...
abuse a truck for 20+ years and it is gonna have issues unless you know the entire history of the truck.
I have had my '81 for 6 years..before that it had 20 owners...you should see some of the crap I have been fixing over the years.
Bullet Proof and uber Reliable reputations are directly related to proper maintenance...
#15
I finnally land an 86 yota in good shape, a year and a half ago. I always wanted one. I'm not so sure anymore... 
So, i thought that these yota trucks were supposed to have the best, most reliable motors in them. But I hear about too many head gaskets...
I replaced the radiator this fall with a proper flush and new fluid. The rad level kept going down. I thought it was just some air in the heater core. Finally topped off I think but fluid going down. Now i have some pressure in the coolant system when stone cold. My oil level is rising and the radiator fluid is going (you guessed it) where it does not belong!! I have not confirmed its in the oil pan yet but there is some moisture (chocolate crud) under the oil cap.
It apperas this motor already had a new head on it by PO. So what gives?! Whats with the #[%^[+ head gaskets?!
How often do these motors have to be rebuilt? Even a new head gasket is not what i need to be doing w/ a newborn and no shop or extra vehicle. I need to get to work...
Just bummed

So, i thought that these yota trucks were supposed to have the best, most reliable motors in them. But I hear about too many head gaskets...
I replaced the radiator this fall with a proper flush and new fluid. The rad level kept going down. I thought it was just some air in the heater core. Finally topped off I think but fluid going down. Now i have some pressure in the coolant system when stone cold. My oil level is rising and the radiator fluid is going (you guessed it) where it does not belong!! I have not confirmed its in the oil pan yet but there is some moisture (chocolate crud) under the oil cap.
It apperas this motor already had a new head on it by PO. So what gives?! Whats with the #[%^[+ head gaskets?!
How often do these motors have to be rebuilt? Even a new head gasket is not what i need to be doing w/ a newborn and no shop or extra vehicle. I need to get to work...

Just bummed

#16
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: central new york state (DeRuyter)
Thanks for all the ideas, support and a good dose of reality.
Sorry about the complaining, it's just at a bad time. I was overreacting.

I really do love my yota
Sorry about the complaining, it's just at a bad time. I was overreacting.

I really do love my yota
Last edited by kirkerik; Feb 15, 2013 at 07:11 AM.
#17
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: central new york state (DeRuyter)
A 22RE is only as reliable as the person who rebuilt it/maintained it....
go to eBay and search ENGNBLDR or go to ENGNBLDR.com and call them.
Get an OEM HG, and get the Front End Kit (timing chain, cover, water & oil pump and gaskets...for like $150). The HG is less than $50 OEM online....toyotapartszone.
do it right. Then complain when it breaks
Tons of guides online....check out user 92 TOY's write up in his signature.
go to eBay and search ENGNBLDR or go to ENGNBLDR.com and call them.
Get an OEM HG, and get the Front End Kit (timing chain, cover, water & oil pump and gaskets...for like $150). The HG is less than $50 OEM online....toyotapartszone.
do it right. Then complain when it breaks

Tons of guides online....check out user 92 TOY's write up in his signature.
I'll check out 92 TOY'S write up.
#18
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
From: central new york state (DeRuyter)
You have no idea what could have caused the head gasket failure.
As an example I had a heater hose fail yes it did get a little hot till I could get it off the road. And repair about 2 weeks later I had a head gasket failure.
Then the fact that most people don`t know the little error Toyota had with under torquing the head bolts so a failure down the road is a real good possibility

As an example I had a heater hose fail yes it did get a little hot till I could get it off the road. And repair about 2 weeks later I had a head gasket failure.
Then the fact that most people don`t know the little error Toyota had with under torquing the head bolts so a failure down the road is a real good possibility
I don't know the torque of head bolts applies here, as i have an aftermarket head from PO. They forgot the EGR and messed up the exhaust pipe gasket. Seems a little sloppy to me. So i am skeptical of the quality of replacement head. What are the proper torque specs then? I'm sure i'll need them.
This thread i started tells some about my head:https://www.yotatech.com/forums/f116...e-head-244436/
how many people have owned the truck ahead of you? How many actually did any up keep?
abuse a truck for 20+ years and it is gonna have issues unless you know the entire history of the truck.
I have had my '81 for 6 years..before that it had 20 owners...you should see some of the crap I have been fixing over the years.
Bullet Proof and uber Reliable reputations are directly related to proper maintenance...
abuse a truck for 20+ years and it is gonna have issues unless you know the entire history of the truck.
I have had my '81 for 6 years..before that it had 20 owners...you should see some of the crap I have been fixing over the years.
Bullet Proof and uber Reliable reputations are directly related to proper maintenance...

I don't want to afford another vehicle, so it's time to wrench this one right. I enjoy it too. Just have to make some time for it.
#19
About half of my repairs have uncovered bone-head mistakes on my truck too. I'm no master mechanic but when you see your cam brackets numbered 1-4-2-3 (didn't pass kindergarten I guess?) in the engine and a sensor that had been ripped in half and then put back to disguise the mistake, I get a little upset.
Some of the smaller mistakes I've seen have been when I had the truck put in to the shop right after I bought it for some routine maintenance. It's not just the owners that mess up sometimes mechanics forget things or make mistakes too. Not bashing mechanics, there are plenty of good shops out there with very good mechanics (there's one that I trust who does a great job, former Toyota mechanic who has the same truck I do).
Some of the smaller mistakes I've seen have been when I had the truck put in to the shop right after I bought it for some routine maintenance. It's not just the owners that mess up sometimes mechanics forget things or make mistakes too. Not bashing mechanics, there are plenty of good shops out there with very good mechanics (there's one that I trust who does a great job, former Toyota mechanic who has the same truck I do).
#20
I won't reiterate what the others above me said about previous owners work, blowing coolant hoses, etc... the possibilities are endless!
That being said, I bought my '94 Pickup seven years ago with exactly 100k miles on it. It now has 200k on it as of yesterday. I replaced the head gasket five years ago. Previous owner said he'd overheated it one time, it lasted two years into my ownership before the HG leaked enough to replace. Of course, when I did pop, I was 240 miles from home in a blizzard. I drove that 240 miles in the blizzard for hours, constantly filling my radiator on the way at rest stations. I was one of the only people on the road, with 6" of snow on I90 East, and I87 South.
I made it home, and parked in my driveway with about 8" of snow. I shut the truck off for the first time in hours. When I tried to restart it to move it a bit, I could hear coolant slosh out of the exhaust. I didn't try again.
I put a new HG in that week every day after work until dark (which comes early in late December/ early January. Once I got the job done, I flushed the whole system, ran two oil changes through it, one after the first ten minutes, the second after 100 miles. The truck has run like a top ever since with just basic preventative maintenance. I've been wanting to swap in my 7MGTE, but the 22re JUST. WON'T. DIE. It just keeps going.
Blame your misfortunes on the previous owners. It's certainly not the truck's fault.
That being said, I bought my '94 Pickup seven years ago with exactly 100k miles on it. It now has 200k on it as of yesterday. I replaced the head gasket five years ago. Previous owner said he'd overheated it one time, it lasted two years into my ownership before the HG leaked enough to replace. Of course, when I did pop, I was 240 miles from home in a blizzard. I drove that 240 miles in the blizzard for hours, constantly filling my radiator on the way at rest stations. I was one of the only people on the road, with 6" of snow on I90 East, and I87 South.
I made it home, and parked in my driveway with about 8" of snow. I shut the truck off for the first time in hours. When I tried to restart it to move it a bit, I could hear coolant slosh out of the exhaust. I didn't try again.
I put a new HG in that week every day after work until dark (which comes early in late December/ early January. Once I got the job done, I flushed the whole system, ran two oil changes through it, one after the first ten minutes, the second after 100 miles. The truck has run like a top ever since with just basic preventative maintenance. I've been wanting to swap in my 7MGTE, but the 22re JUST. WON'T. DIE. It just keeps going.
Blame your misfortunes on the previous owners. It's certainly not the truck's fault.



