3.4L Turbo or Supercharger?
#41
Keeping the flow separate until the turbo is a good idea to maximize performance and try to remove any uneven flow between the banks.
Plus twin scroll offers performance advantages as well if properly implemented.
If it is too hard to do a true twin scroll though a normal single scroll will work fine as well, nothing to beat yourself up about. Although I do recommend a Vband turbine housing if single scroll, makes things a lot neater and easier to work with.
If you do your own fab work I would also look into the intake manifold. The runner are just way too dang long. I would cut the runners off and install a large custom plenum to improve top end performance.
A significant part of why the supercharger seems to work so much better is the fact it shortens the runners down to almost nothing. Thus drastically improving the top end vs stock.
#42
Are there any examples of custom short ram plenum? I've seen, was it Gadget's or Speedy's or whoevers with the twin turbo setup. I'm not fabricator, but I could probably hack something together if I had an example. Enough grinding and paint can cover a lot of mistakes! Slacker, if you wanna make a couple of those in the future, you've got a customer here. Also if you ever make a driver side (3.4 swap style) turbo manifold, I would also be interested.
Last edited by vasinvictor; Mar 20, 2015 at 07:09 AM.
#43
Are there any examples of custom short ram plenum? I've seen, was it Gadget's or Speedy's or whoevers with the twin turbo setup. I'm not fabricator, but I could probably hack something together if I had an example. Enough grinding and paint can cover a lot of mistakes! Slacker, if you wanna make a couple of those in the future, you've got a customer here. Also if you ever make a driver side (3.4 swap style) turbo manifold, I would also be interested.
Here are some pictures of my old dual plenum manifold to give you ideas. The runners are stock, the plenum is obviously custom along with the second set of backwards firing injectors for what was going to be the ultimate meth injection kit:





#44
Factory plenum is aluminum, right? I can't weld that. I'd have to find somebody. How about using a 4" piece of exhaust tubing as basis for plenum? I have an extra motor and plenum to play with. Do you think the TB can still stay on the side like it is factory, or should it be in the front of the plenum?
Where do you get that log with one flat side like you used on yours?
Where do you get that log with one flat side like you used on yours?
Last edited by vasinvictor; Mar 20, 2015 at 09:51 AM.
#45
Factory plenum is aluminum, right? I can't weld that. I'd have to find somebody. How about using a 4" piece of exhaust tubing as basis for plenum? I have an extra motor and plenum to play with. Do you think the TB can still stay on the side like it is factory, or should it be in the front of the plenum?
Where do you get that log with one flat side like you used on yours?
Where do you get that log with one flat side like you used on yours?
The TB can be put wherever it will allow for even flow, generally it is best to have it on the end of the plenum unless you design it for another direction.
The plenum was made out of half a piece of pipe and a flat piece of aluminum welded together. The second plenum is uneeded, it is for perfect distribution in high performance applications.
#46
If you will be building the manifold yourself then I highly suggest building a Twin-scroll manifold with each bank of cylinders feeding a scroll.
Keeping the flow separate until the turbo is a good idea to maximize performance and try to remove any uneven flow between the banks.
Plus twin scroll offers performance advantages as well if properly implemented.
If it is too hard to do a true twin scroll though a normal single scroll will work fine as well, nothing to beat yourself up about. Although I do recommend a Vband turbine housing if single scroll, makes things a lot neater and easier to work with.
Keeping the flow separate until the turbo is a good idea to maximize performance and try to remove any uneven flow between the banks.
Plus twin scroll offers performance advantages as well if properly implemented.
If it is too hard to do a true twin scroll though a normal single scroll will work fine as well, nothing to beat yourself up about. Although I do recommend a Vband turbine housing if single scroll, makes things a lot neater and easier to work with.
If you do your own fab work I would also look into the intake manifold. The runner are just way too dang long. I would cut the runners off and install a large custom plenum to improve top end performance.
A significant part of why the supercharger seems to work so much better is the fact it shortens the runners down to almost nothing. Thus drastically improving the top end vs stock.
.
#47
Instead of the driver side manifold connecting to the passenger side like the CX setup does. It would simply bypass the passenger side manifold and run directly up to the Turbo flange.
Fitment would be tight in some areas but very possible.
Obviously the runner lengths would be different, while not 100% ideal, it is better.
Twins are another option and would work but would be a real fitment pain with the battery. Plus add extra weight and offer no real performance advantage.
#48
do you think a URD piggy back would work for this application ? I have a spare one
and where do I buy the turbo flanges .. anyone have a good deal on these ?
.
and where do I buy the turbo flanges .. anyone have a good deal on these ?
.
Last edited by slacker; Mar 21, 2015 at 07:24 PM.
#49


[/hijack]
Last edited by Robert m; Mar 22, 2015 at 01:20 PM. Reason: fixed broken pics
#50
Besides that with a turbo setup you will most likely overrun what even the 7th injector can handle.
You will need to either get a piggyback that can control a full set of extra injectors or take over control of a larger set of stock injectors. The AEM FIC can do both of these.
I am a fan of an extra set of injectors myself since you let the stock ECU take care of everything out of boost and thus it drives like stock. Things only change when in boost and the extra injectors kick in along with any timing changes ect. Since this is open loop the ECU plays a lot nicer like this as well.
#54
http://www.full-race.com/articles/ef...uidelines.html
Garrett's GT and GTX turbos have water cooling... In fact, Garrett even has a white paper titled "Water-Cooled Turbochargers: They Need Water!"
https://www.turbobygarrett.com/turbo...er_Cooling.pdf
You see water cooling more on ball bearing turbos because they don't require as much oil flow as their journal bearing counterparts. To say that modern turbos don't have watercooling is an inaccurate statement.
#55
LOL! At least you're honest about it...
#56
Borg Warner has EFR turbos that are water cooled... Even the install instructions state "Water cooling is particularly critical on EFR turbos equipped with aluminum bearing housings!"
http://www.full-race.com/articles/ef...uidelines.html
Garrett's GT and GTX turbos have water cooling... In fact, Garrett even has a white paper titled "Water-Cooled Turbochargers: They Need Water!"
https://www.turbobygarrett.com/turbo...er_Cooling.pdf
You see water cooling more on ball bearing turbos because they don't require as much oil flow as their journal bearing counterparts. To say that modern turbos don't have watercooling is an inaccurate statement.
http://www.full-race.com/articles/ef...uidelines.html
Garrett's GT and GTX turbos have water cooling... In fact, Garrett even has a white paper titled "Water-Cooled Turbochargers: They Need Water!"
https://www.turbobygarrett.com/turbo...er_Cooling.pdf
You see water cooling more on ball bearing turbos because they don't require as much oil flow as their journal bearing counterparts. To say that modern turbos don't have watercooling is an inaccurate statement.
Garret is a joke, I refuse to talk about there overpriced and under preforming stuff. They have not had a competitive turbo in 10 years.
PTE on the other hand leads the pack and they are oil cooled only. That includes the ball bearing models and they use ceramic ball bearings and they do not need the coolant. So yes, I can 100% say that modern turbos do not need coolant.
Oh yeah, comp does the same thing, heck they have oilless turbos now as well.
It is all pointless anyways, not like it matters if the turbo is oil or water cooled. It makes boost, that all that matters.
Last edited by Texas_Ace; Mar 23, 2015 at 11:37 AM.
#57
so do you think I can use the Holset hx35 's for a twin set up , or is this to much ?
I have 2 sets of larger injectors .. not positive on the CC's yet (more research) I plan on intercooling , twin oil ports , pressure reg , boos controller , BOV , air temp sensor . meth , wide band , and stand alone (not sure which one yet ?)
I'm just not sure on the turbos ? I'm thinkin with the control I should have , they will be ok
I'm not going to rebuild the engine , or do stronger internals yet .. just want to do this to start
.
I have 2 sets of larger injectors .. not positive on the CC's yet (more research) I plan on intercooling , twin oil ports , pressure reg , boos controller , BOV , air temp sensor . meth , wide band , and stand alone (not sure which one yet ?)
I'm just not sure on the turbos ? I'm thinkin with the control I should have , they will be ok
I'm not going to rebuild the engine , or do stronger internals yet .. just want to do this to start
.
#58
#59
#60
What are you wanting to do with your boost? I couldn't love my hx35 more. It drives like stock but is really a blast when you put the pedal down. If you're wanting really low end boost, this is not the turbo you want. It's a little large, and could be smaller and still stay efficient. I don't need/want any extra torque down low for wheeling- that's how parts break anyway. I can drive all day like stock but very easily push it into boost at 3k. I'll bet the boost threshold for a twin scroll hx35 would be lower than mine, especially properly mounted nearer the manifolds. When I was choosing a turbo the compressor map matched exactly what I wanted to do- in fact was recommended by Ace and other members. Ultra reliable, rock solid turbo.









