Get what you want, and then you will not have buyer's remorse later. When I was SASing my 4Runner and decided to upgrade my tires, I debated between the 35" tires and the 37" tires. I wanted the 37" tires, but was a little hessitant on the price. My wife talked me into the 37" tires, and I couldn't be more happy with this decision. These 37s really fit my 4Runner well, and they have done absolutely awesome on the highway and off-road.