Question for all the Stick/ 5 Spd/ Manual Drivers?
#42
Contributing Member
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 2,226
Likes: 0
From: Houston (home), Atlanta (school), Cincinnati (work)
i love my 5spd, but the ONLY argument i PERSONALLY have for wanting an auto is for some offroading. generally my 5spd is great offroad and the tranny braking is great, but when im up against a ledge, with my stock t-case gearing and all i either have to try to back up and get a running start (not always possible) or burn up my clutch feathering it so i can get up that ledge. if i had lower crawler gears that wouldnt be an issue. i feel an auto in that particular case would be much easier to use.
#47
I will not drive a slush box. Period. I loved them until I drove a stick. I don't care If i drive through town, on hills, I'd still take stick over automatic. My motorhome has a automatic 22re, gutless with a capital LESS. Every time I drive it I wish it was a stick.
One exception would be if you are disabled like my Grandpa is and needs an automatic.
One exception would be if you are disabled like my Grandpa is and needs an automatic.
#48
go manual...
My 97 runner has 205K miles and the original clutch. 3.4 with a 5spd. I take her on the beach and would not trade that 5spd for an auto no matter what I was offered. 2nd and 3rd gear are a blast with lots of torque.
Go for the manual!! Autos are for soccer moms...
#51
honestly my auto 99 was faster but the stick is much more fun on the trail and street...im not a fast driver so for me the stick is way better, if you drive fast stay with an auto. but i wouldnt trade my manual for anything
#52
#53
If you prefer a manual tranny, you should get what makes you happy. For 4 cyl engines and V6s w/ modest power I think a manual is much better. My yota has one and I like it.
Ultimately you have to be happy with it!
#54
Why of course! We really need MORE government interference in our lives because there just isn't enough already, in fact, there can NEVER BE ENOUGH! Great idea!
If you prefer a manual tranny, you should get what makes you happy. For 4 cyl engines and V6s w/ modest power I think a manual is much better. My yota has one and I like it.
Ultimately you have to be happy with it!
If you prefer a manual tranny, you should get what makes you happy. For 4 cyl engines and V6s w/ modest power I think a manual is much better. My yota has one and I like it.
Ultimately you have to be happy with it!
#55
i'm a sucker of sticks, over the years, vehicles i've owned are:
85 Accord, 4cyl stick,
89 RX-7 1.3L rotor, stick
00 Accord coupe 4cyl stick(bought new)
04 Ram1500 4.7L auto(leased new)
94 4Runner 3.slow stick. (since april 07)
do the swap, you won't be sorry. but make sure you do it right or have a pro do it.
85 Accord, 4cyl stick,
89 RX-7 1.3L rotor, stick
00 Accord coupe 4cyl stick(bought new)
04 Ram1500 4.7L auto(leased new)
94 4Runner 3.slow stick. (since april 07)
do the swap, you won't be sorry. but make sure you do it right or have a pro do it.
Last edited by TC4RNR; Mar 1, 2008 at 12:07 AM.
#59
#60
I would hesitate to say an auto is faster or slower than a manual.
I will say it an auto is more consistent that a manual.
Woman would drag race her suburban every weekend in stock class.
She won every weekend also. Consistency was her game. She knew what times the truck would run and she had it pegged every time. End of season, she took the trophy home.
Consistent. All it was. Nothing fancy, just a normal Suburban that Mrs Soccer mom drove everyday.
I will say it an auto is more consistent that a manual.
Woman would drag race her suburban every weekend in stock class.
She won every weekend also. Consistency was her game. She knew what times the truck would run and she had it pegged every time. End of season, she took the trophy home.
Consistent. All it was. Nothing fancy, just a normal Suburban that Mrs Soccer mom drove everyday.




Auto faster? I doubt it.