Battery, Battery, which one to pick...
#1
Contributing Member
Thread Starter
Battery, Battery, which one to pick...
Ok, my battery is just about dead. It has got to go. So i am woundering what battrery i should get to replace it.
I will be using a fair amount of power without the enigne running so i need a battery that will last. It is not uncommon for me to have to leave the lights for a good while without it running. Or have the radio on (i will have a nice one once i get it installed, 1000W amp ect...)
So should i go with a Optima? or just an oversized normal battery? What "oversized" batterys have ya'll used with good luck? Thanks!
I will be using a fair amount of power without the enigne running so i need a battery that will last. It is not uncommon for me to have to leave the lights for a good while without it running. Or have the radio on (i will have a nice one once i get it installed, 1000W amp ect...)
So should i go with a Optima? or just an oversized normal battery? What "oversized" batterys have ya'll used with good luck? Thanks!
Last edited by Texas_Ace; 05-02-2007 at 04:00 PM.
#4
Contributing Member
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: GSU/ATL/SD
Posts: 1,434
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
depends on how much power you have to drain. if you have soundsystem, lights, and other aux options than an optima red top would be best suited for you. medium power consumption doesn't really require anything special, just look at walmart/autozone, etc.
#6
Contributing Member
Thread Starter
My power drain is not so much fast power drain as long times without recharging and draining.
I just want a battery that i can count on and won't die anytime soon.
I figured i would just go with a regular battery but wanted to see what ya'll had to say. Thanks for the info!
I just want a battery that i can count on and won't die anytime soon.
I figured i would just go with a regular battery but wanted to see what ya'll had to say. Thanks for the info!
Trending Topics
#9
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Winnipeg, MB, Canada
Posts: 79
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The optima type of battery seem to hold up better to vibration as all the cells are seperate and they have gel in them not liquid. I haven been returning my batt on waranty (on my 4th) every 6 months as the vibration from offroading seems to loosen the plates and grounds the plates together.Anyone else have this problem? Once the warrenty runs out I am getting an optima.
#10
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Idaho
Posts: 4,655
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My power drain is not so much fast power drain as long times without recharging and draining.
I just want a battery that i can count on and won't die anytime soon.
I figured i would just go with a regular battery but wanted to see what ya'll had to say. Thanks for the info!
I just want a battery that i can count on and won't die anytime soon.
I figured i would just go with a regular battery but wanted to see what ya'll had to say. Thanks for the info!
Sounds like a good job for a yellow top. By far best battery I have ever owned. Its in my 3rd rig right now, 7 years later. It will take the type of abuse you are going to put it thru with long drains between charges. I once killed my yellow top deader than dead, I left the dome light on for 6 weeks with the truck parked. When I got home the truck wouldnt start, measured the voltage at .010, any other battery would have been a boat anchor at this time. Put a charger on it for 24 hours and it was back up and running, that was 3 years ago, not one issue since.
Based on how you described your usage I would not get a red top, if you kill them once they are done for good.
linky
#11
Contributing Member
Thread Starter
I have been looking at batteries for the last week and hereis what i have found now that i have some un-baised input.
There are actually only about 3 - 4 car battery manufactures. Those few make all the car batteries in the US. they just put differnt lables on them.
Although i do want to best battery i can get i also don't have unlimited funds. I have been really wanting that yellow top but there are 2 thimgs keeping me from it.
1 : it costs $160 vs $75
2 : the red top and other batteries have 3 year free replacement + 72 mo proreated. The yellow top has a 1 year free replacement and 36 mo prorated (i think, might be a little more but it is a lot less than other batteries).
Your example with the dome light is now making me think twice about the warranty thing though...
There are actually only about 3 - 4 car battery manufactures. Those few make all the car batteries in the US. they just put differnt lables on them.
Although i do want to best battery i can get i also don't have unlimited funds. I have been really wanting that yellow top but there are 2 thimgs keeping me from it.
1 : it costs $160 vs $75
2 : the red top and other batteries have 3 year free replacement + 72 mo proreated. The yellow top has a 1 year free replacement and 36 mo prorated (i think, might be a little more but it is a lot less than other batteries).
Your example with the dome light is now making me think twice about the warranty thing though...
#12
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Idaho
Posts: 4,655
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have been looking at batteries for the last week and hereis what i have found now that i have some un-baised input.
There are actually only about 3 - 4 car battery manufactures. Those few make all the car batteries in the US. they just put differnt lables on them.
Although i do want to best battery i can get i also don't have unlimited funds. I have been really wanting that yellow top but there are 2 thimgs keeping me from it.
1 : it costs $160 vs $75
2 : the red top and other batteries have 3 year free replacement + 72 mo proreated. The yellow top has a 1 year free replacement and 36 mo prorated (i think, might be a little more but it is a lot less than other batteries).
Your example with the dome light is now making me think twice about the warranty thing though...
There are actually only about 3 - 4 car battery manufactures. Those few make all the car batteries in the US. they just put differnt lables on them.
Although i do want to best battery i can get i also don't have unlimited funds. I have been really wanting that yellow top but there are 2 thimgs keeping me from it.
1 : it costs $160 vs $75
2 : the red top and other batteries have 3 year free replacement + 72 mo proreated. The yellow top has a 1 year free replacement and 36 mo prorated (i think, might be a little more but it is a lot less than other batteries).
Your example with the dome light is now making me think twice about the warranty thing though...
#13
Contributing Member
Thread Starter
And i agree that the yellow is the way to go. The smaller warranty just made me wounder if it would last or if it was a battery that would go out in a year...
#14
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Idaho
Posts: 4,655
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You know come to think of it that price was at a PX on an army base... got any military buddies??
I think the warranty is shorter due to the intended nature of a deep cycle.... you can expect to deep drain and recharge and be okay, but I dont think they will survive more than a few complete drainings...
I think the warranty is shorter due to the intended nature of a deep cycle.... you can expect to deep drain and recharge and be okay, but I dont think they will survive more than a few complete drainings...
#15
Contributing Member
Thread Starter
True, i think you are right. It is like lawn mowers, you can get the honda residentual and it will have a 3 year waranty or get the commerical and only get a 1 year...
I will have to check with a few guys i know at the local military base....
I will have to check with a few guys i know at the local military base....
#16
Optima's can have reliability issues. Several of my friends have used them and the AZ heat just kills them. Pretty pathetic. Other brands offer a much better product, but don't have the marketing driving them like Optima does.
I recommend Odyssey or the Exide Orbital XCD (what I have; $150 shipped). These are better options than the Optima, especially the unbeatable Odysseys. I used an Odyssey PC680 (aircraft size) for 2 seasons in my Honda daily driver/road racer mounted right near the header in the Arizona heat and even drained it completely several times. The battery NEVER failed in the toughest conditions I could imagine for any battery. It's the best you can buy...
I recommend Odyssey or the Exide Orbital XCD (what I have; $150 shipped). These are better options than the Optima, especially the unbeatable Odysseys. I used an Odyssey PC680 (aircraft size) for 2 seasons in my Honda daily driver/road racer mounted right near the header in the Arizona heat and even drained it completely several times. The battery NEVER failed in the toughest conditions I could imagine for any battery. It's the best you can buy...
#17
Contributing Member
Thread Starter
You know, those Odyssey's are starting to look good. I never even really looked at them since no one local sold them and i thought shipping would be outrages.
so has anyone mounted one of them in a 4runner? What model to get...
so has anyone mounted one of them in a 4runner? What model to get...
Last edited by Texas_Ace; 05-02-2007 at 08:15 PM.
#19
Contributing Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Summit County, Colorado
Posts: 899
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Optimas are manufactured in their own plant near Denver International Airport. The company is part of Johnson Controls, and Johnson Controls is one of the biggest automotive battery manufacturers in the world - they produce many OEM and private branded batteries (including Interstate).
To the best of my knowledge, the Optima plant is a stand-alone operation in Colorado, and it is considered the flagship of the Johnson Controls brands - the only one mentioned, by name, on the J.C. website.
Just wanted to point that out, since Optima is a long time Colorado company. They were developed here, and are still manufactured here.
To the best of my knowledge, the Optima plant is a stand-alone operation in Colorado, and it is considered the flagship of the Johnson Controls brands - the only one mentioned, by name, on the J.C. website.
Just wanted to point that out, since Optima is a long time Colorado company. They were developed here, and are still manufactured here.
#20
Contributing Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Tigard, Oregon
Posts: 2,097
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You know, those Odyssey's are starting to look good. Especially since i looked up there price. I never even really looked at them since no one local sold them and i thought shipping would be outrages.
so has anyone mounted one of them in a 4runner? What model to get...
so has anyone mounted one of them in a 4runner? What model to get...
If I remember right, they have a 10 year life expectancy.