View Poll Results: Automatic or 5 spd Manual?
Automatic



27
26.47%
5 spd Manual



75
73.53%
Voters: 102. You may not vote on this poll
Auto vrs 5spd
#21
Originally Posted by PoBoy
What makes it so much harder to work on and more expeinsive? I was under the assumption that they were very similar engines, just one was larger and more powerful. I guess so many of you guys got the factory rebuild paid for by Toy that I havent seen many bills for rebuilds.
Ugg...why do you guys do this too me!! I was totally set on a 2nd gen
The cruise control issue I had with my '96 modded sticks in my head though. I drive a lot and hated it constantly dropping into 3rd on the slightest incline. Now, Im gonna have the same issue with an unmodded 2nd gen. GRRR!!! Where is that guy that is putting 3.4Ls in 2nd gens?
Ugg...why do you guys do this too me!! I was totally set on a 2nd gen
The cruise control issue I had with my '96 modded sticks in my head though. I drive a lot and hated it constantly dropping into 3rd on the slightest incline. Now, Im gonna have the same issue with an unmodded 2nd gen. GRRR!!! Where is that guy that is putting 3.4Ls in 2nd gens?I really liked the 5spd in my 95, and without it, the truck really would have been sluggish. In all honesty, in the 70-80mph range, stock, I enjoyed the highway manners of my 2nd gen more than my 3rd until it was time to pass, or hit a hill. I'm sure it was all mental as that truck was my baby, and I've had to do a lot of work to my 3rd gen to get that pride of ownership I had out of my stock 2nd gen.
The 2nd is just more of a truck.
...and keeping with my 2am rambling...the one automatic 2nd gen I drove was terribly sluggish and I'd never personally want to own one. Someday I'll own another 2nd gen as my little 2nd car pet project, and it will for sure be a white 5spd just like #1 was.
Good luck finding a truck, there are definitely a lot of 2nd gens floating around town.
#23
I drive in stop and go traffic for 2 hrs everyday. I wish I had an auto. I get so tired of shifting. I also wish I had 2 more cylinders but that is a different story. I had to drive the wifes exploder all last week while waiting for my new brake line. I loved the power (as compaired to my 4 cyl) and the auto tranny in traffic. It actually made the ride to and from work a little better. Now if Toyota would produce a Turbo Desiel Tundra, I would be all over that. Sorry got off topic.
#24
FWIW, I've had my 3.0 Auto with factory 4.88's for over 8 years now. Bought it with 14K on the odo.
I have done minor power mods (and perceived power mods) including: Borla cat back, electric fan, manual hubs, K&N FIPK. The last things I haven't done to boost the engine that are pretty easy (and not too pricey) are adding headers and an overbored throttle body. Those may come some day.
My tire selection went immediately to 32's after I got the rig in 95 (no engine mods initially) for two sets of tires. I recently went to 33's with the 4.88's. It is not bad at all. Am I going to win any drag races? NO. But it can more than get out of its own way now. When I get locked, I am still debating over if I should stay with 4.88's or move to 5.29's. Someday, this rig will have tires bigger than 33's, so I'll probably pony up.
It appears that the 3.0 is expensive to fix/replace hence the increasing prevalence of the 3.4 swap. When (if) mine dies, I'll likely go that route unless a 4.7 isn't alot more work. I would swap the engine/trans/tcase in one shot, btw.
I have done minor power mods (and perceived power mods) including: Borla cat back, electric fan, manual hubs, K&N FIPK. The last things I haven't done to boost the engine that are pretty easy (and not too pricey) are adding headers and an overbored throttle body. Those may come some day.
My tire selection went immediately to 32's after I got the rig in 95 (no engine mods initially) for two sets of tires. I recently went to 33's with the 4.88's. It is not bad at all. Am I going to win any drag races? NO. But it can more than get out of its own way now. When I get locked, I am still debating over if I should stay with 4.88's or move to 5.29's. Someday, this rig will have tires bigger than 33's, so I'll probably pony up.
It appears that the 3.0 is expensive to fix/replace hence the increasing prevalence of the 3.4 swap. When (if) mine dies, I'll likely go that route unless a 4.7 isn't alot more work. I would swap the engine/trans/tcase in one shot, btw.
#26
Originally Posted by PirateFins
I drive in stop and go traffic for 2 hrs everyday.
#27
Originally Posted by Cebby
This is what cured me of wanting a manual again. I no longer have the long commute, but I got sick of shifting.
#28
Originally Posted by <96 Runner>
So you are going from the 3.4 V6 with 33's and 4.10's, to an Auto or 5 spd. 3.0 with stock-sized tires?
It appears that the 3.0 is expensive to fix/replace hence the increasing prevalence of the 3.4 swap. When (if) mine dies, I'll likely go that route unless a 4.7 isn't alot more work. I would swap the engine/trans/tcase in one shot, btw.
#29
I have a '94 P/U with the 3.0 automatic and I have no problem on the hills.
It is relatively slower than most cars and trucks but that's OK with me.
I can keep 75 on ARIZONA's hills if I floor it all the way.
Keep in mind, P/U are much lighter in weight than 4 RUNNERS.
It is relatively slower than most cars and trucks but that's OK with me.
I can keep 75 on ARIZONA's hills if I floor it all the way.
Keep in mind, P/U are much lighter in weight than 4 RUNNERS.
#31
Originally Posted by Juggalo
I know that, but mine's still slow as hell :cry: (even when I had 31's)
I was a delivery for Napa for awhile, and all the rigs were manuals, and I enjoyed the hell out of it. All my vehicles will be manual transmissions. Now if only the Tundra came with a 5speed and V8, I'd be set!
#33
[QUOTE=AgRunner06]Here's my advice to anyone who is going to buy a 2nd gen.
Get a 5 speed.
I wish I had.
Nuff Said! I was looking for a 5Spd when shopping for a Runner but could only find the auto. I wanted a Runner bad enough and didnt want to travel 200+ miles to the cities to find one. I have driven a 94 with a 5spd and I like it better than the auto. the only time I stick up for the auto is when im sticking up for my Runner. I have to give my auto credit for not giving me problems though. Its been a very durable part that ive put through a lot. Blue
Get a 5 speed.
I wish I had.
Nuff Said! I was looking for a 5Spd when shopping for a Runner but could only find the auto. I wanted a Runner bad enough and didnt want to travel 200+ miles to the cities to find one. I have driven a 94 with a 5spd and I like it better than the auto. the only time I stick up for the auto is when im sticking up for my Runner. I have to give my auto credit for not giving me problems though. Its been a very durable part that ive put through a lot. Blue
#38
Originally Posted by 44Runner
I have driven and will always drive manuals.
They are cheaper to purchase.
They rob less power.
They are more fun.
They are cheaper to purchase.
They rob less power.
They are more fun.

i just wish modern car companies would stop taking away our option to buy a manual nowadays...
#39
Thread Starter
Contributing Member
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 737
Likes: 0
From: The rolling hills of Cavan, Ontario
Well, I drove 5 different automatics today, and for various and sundry reassons, I didn't like ANY of them. Nowhere near the same drive as the 5spd, extra noises I couldn't identify and just the thought of all the magic that has to occur before the rubber hits the road makes my mind wobble :pat:
I'm not knocking the auto, because everyone here has posted some good reasons for having one...long commutes in raffic might be enough to sway me. But I only do 14 tours a month and just 4 of them involve weekday morning traffic, so I'm not there yet
Kyle 22r makes a great point...I think it has to do with soccer moms being the descision makers now!
I'm not knocking the auto, because everyone here has posted some good reasons for having one...long commutes in raffic might be enough to sway me. But I only do 14 tours a month and just 4 of them involve weekday morning traffic, so I'm not there yet
Kyle 22r makes a great point...I think it has to do with soccer moms being the descision makers now!
#40
I vote for the 5spd with the 3.0. yeah its a bitch in traffic but the as long as you don't ride it the clutch can take it with no complaints. What i'll some times do in heavy traffic is leave a little room (if posible) go 1 2 then neutral and coast up to the guy in front usually they're moving by then and its back into 2 for a little pop then neutral again. it saves gas clutch and my leg :-). + its way more fun. My hilux with a full tool load in the rear can still walk a 5.0 off the line (at least across the intersection anyway then...) but we don't drive these things for the speed do we...go with the 5spd Cheers Aviator


Huh wierd, it looks ok to me.