Been looking for some good used fenders around in Ohio but not finding any one looked on eBay and seen some sets with good prices but not to sure on the fit was wondering if anyone had a good place to order fenders from

 

I know LowRange Off Road has some but I can't speak for the quality. Or, if you want fancy rust-proof with custom options there's always toyotafiberglass dot com. Nice stuff from a guy in canada

 

Used, reproduction, or fix what you have.

The fiberglass ones have a good reputation, the steel ones a little less so (I don't remember specifics but nothing you can not get around with some tweaking and a grinder from what I recall). To the best of my recollection all the steel ones come out of the same factory regardless of where you're buying them or who's name is on the box.

 

I bought one left front from Rock auto for my 86 4R.
I measured the metal thickness compared to the original and they were very close.
It bolted on and the lines looked good, but the bottom bolt holes did not align by about a half inch.
To fix it, I would have enlarged the bolt hole and then mig weld a washer to the fender.
All in all, with a little work it would have been a fine replacement but I decided to try to keep my original metal instead.