Help a Newb with his 22RE ... Replace the Head Gasket or Get A Rebuilt Engine???
#21
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Sonora, CA (Central Sierra)
Posts: 447
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#22
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Sonora, CA (Central Sierra)
Posts: 447
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If the inside of your cylinder looks like that, and the PO didn't drive it for 6 months, that water and coolant is all over the inside of that block. You will hate yourself in 10,000 miles if you just clean up the top end and bolt it back together. You basically have two good options:
1) Buy a rebuilt motor, from Attarco or the like. You are looking at 650-750$ for this, but you get a newly re-built motor very quickly, and you can slap it right in with no problems and no further work to engine internals. Attach, tune up, slap in some belts and plug wires, and drive off.
2) Pull your motor and rebuild it. Your crank bearings are dubious after marinating in coolant for 6 months, and so are you rings, cam bearings, cylinder walls, etc. This will cost anything from 450$ to $2,000, depending on how crazy you get during the rebuild. An average rebuild with moderately good parts will cost you about $600.
For most armchair mechanics, the smart money is on the rebuilt motor, instead of re-building your own. Re-building your own is wonderful, if you have the tools, space, time, and money to do it well. I have done both, and if you just want to get a running truck in a hurry, grab the rebuilt from Attarco, you can't lose.
#23
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Nashville TN. I can help you if you're close BUT NOBODY CAN HELP YOU IF YOU DON'T FILL YOUR LOCATION IN!
Posts: 1,818
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Let me give you a word of advice:
If the inside of your cylinder looks like that, and the PO didn't drive it for 6 months, that water and coolant is all over the inside of that block. You will hate yourself in 10,000 miles if you just clean up the top end and bolt it back together. You basically have two good options:
If the inside of your cylinder looks like that, and the PO didn't drive it for 6 months, that water and coolant is all over the inside of that block. You will hate yourself in 10,000 miles if you just clean up the top end and bolt it back together. You basically have two good options:
It's nice that the 22R is an engine that can go 10,000 in that condition though... if it had to...
Another option is to just pull the pistons and glaze break it...
You can put lower bearings in and new rings, and just pay to have the head reworked...
Easy and doable... and cheap...
I love these motors...
Damngit! Profanity warning,,, guy drops the F bomb...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89AxuhEHc3o
Last edited by tried4x2signN; 04-01-2010 at 09:53 PM.
#24
Registered User
Thread Starter
Pumkinyota, thanks, that is what I am thinking. Basically I don't have much trust in what the OP said. He was a nice guy, but I never trust what anyone says when they are trying to sell me something.
I just can't do all the work on top and let this mess go on the bottom. For me, having this one rebuilt, or getting a remanufactured one is the only way to go.
So my top choices are autospecengines.com which is here in AZ, has a 2 year warranty, and I talked to Phan and he said he can use metal valve guides and timing chain guide for a little extra. He is out of cores so he will actually rebuild mine--which I kinda like for some reason. Also, I am gonna spring $150 extra for a new head, as long as it is a new casting.
I also have another builder here in AZ getting me a quote on a Jordan remanufactured longblock. Somehow I think this will be in the $1500 range.
And Attarco is something I will look into.
Basically, I just want it done right so I don't get stranded when I am out in the desert!
I just can't do all the work on top and let this mess go on the bottom. For me, having this one rebuilt, or getting a remanufactured one is the only way to go.
So my top choices are autospecengines.com which is here in AZ, has a 2 year warranty, and I talked to Phan and he said he can use metal valve guides and timing chain guide for a little extra. He is out of cores so he will actually rebuild mine--which I kinda like for some reason. Also, I am gonna spring $150 extra for a new head, as long as it is a new casting.
I also have another builder here in AZ getting me a quote on a Jordan remanufactured longblock. Somehow I think this will be in the $1500 range.
And Attarco is something I will look into.
Basically, I just want it done right so I don't get stranded when I am out in the desert!
#27
Registered User
Thread Starter
This was the reply I got within a few hours from Attarco.
"The engine is a brand new engine. The valve guides are metal, the timing guides are the stock plastic. The engine comes with a 6 month warranty. Shipping to a business with a forklift or loading dock to unload the engine from a freight truck, or shipping to the freight terminal for pick up will be $125."
Wow, this sounds really good. But I can't change out the timing chain guide without pulling the front cover and head, correct? If so I think I would just leave it.
"The engine is a brand new engine. The valve guides are metal, the timing guides are the stock plastic. The engine comes with a 6 month warranty. Shipping to a business with a forklift or loading dock to unload the engine from a freight truck, or shipping to the freight terminal for pick up will be $125."
Wow, this sounds really good. But I can't change out the timing chain guide without pulling the front cover and head, correct? If so I think I would just leave it.
#28
Registered User
Thread Starter
One of the bolt holes on my intake manifold is broken. No big deal but I figured I would get a new one if I could find one cheap. So I look on Craigslist and there is one for $25! Sweet! I e-mailed and got a reply this evening...
"Sorry, went off to scrap today."
Bummer! What a waste!
"Sorry, went off to scrap today."
Bummer! What a waste!
#29
Registered User
Thread Starter
I got the engine out completely and did some pressure washing. I got a little ahead of myself when pulling the engine and forgot to take off the hood. Then I got it all the way up and the lower part of the oil pan wouldn't clear the core support--it was actually pretty funny as I held up the hood and then just lifted the back end of the engine over the core support!
This engine was trashed IMHO. There were metal shavings in the pick up and the bottom of the oil pan was just mud and muck! No problem though. By taking my time and listening to the advice on this site I have everything read to go to autospecengines.com. I went down there and talked to Phan. He is a great guy and I like what I see. He will upgrade to a new casting head, metal valve guides and metal timing chain guide for reasonable money.
Wish me luck!
This engine was trashed IMHO. There were metal shavings in the pick up and the bottom of the oil pan was just mud and muck! No problem though. By taking my time and listening to the advice on this site I have everything read to go to autospecengines.com. I went down there and talked to Phan. He is a great guy and I like what I see. He will upgrade to a new casting head, metal valve guides and metal timing chain guide for reasonable money.
Wish me luck!
#30
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Sonora, CA (Central Sierra)
Posts: 447
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This was the reply I got within a few hours from Attarco.
"The engine is a brand new engine. The valve guides are metal, the timing guides are the stock plastic. The engine comes with a 6 month warranty. Shipping to a business with a forklift or loading dock to unload the engine from a freight truck, or shipping to the freight terminal for pick up will be $125."
Wow, this sounds really good. But I can't change out the timing chain guide without pulling the front cover and head, correct? If so I think I would just leave it.
"The engine is a brand new engine. The valve guides are metal, the timing guides are the stock plastic. The engine comes with a 6 month warranty. Shipping to a business with a forklift or loading dock to unload the engine from a freight truck, or shipping to the freight terminal for pick up will be $125."
Wow, this sounds really good. But I can't change out the timing chain guide without pulling the front cover and head, correct? If so I think I would just leave it.
Sorry for the lack of replies, I have been SWAMPED for weeks now...
You can change the TC guides without pulling the head, all you need to pull is the timing cover. If you wanted, you could get away with a lot of mileage without replacing those guides though. On the flip side, the easiest time to replace the guides would be with the motor out, so its a 50/50 wash...
#31
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Sonora, CA (Central Sierra)
Posts: 447
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#32
Registered User
Thread Starter
No problem man, thanks for all the input! I am just excited to be moving forward.
Hey, is there a place you like to get part from? Like power steering hoses and transmission mount...
Oh, and is there a radiator upgrade? I have searched a few times but can't find anything. And then there is the question of clutch fan over electric.
Sorry to keep asking! 8)
Hey, is there a place you like to get part from? Like power steering hoses and transmission mount...
Oh, and is there a radiator upgrade? I have searched a few times but can't find anything. And then there is the question of clutch fan over electric.
Sorry to keep asking! 8)
#33
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Sonora, CA (Central Sierra)
Posts: 447
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As far as parts houses, I have always had fairly good success with Kragen/CSK and Napa. There are some online sources that are reputed to be excellent, the only one that I have had any personal dealings with is LC Engineering. They have a premium product, and great customer support, but sometimes you pay a premium price for their product. Still and all, my experiences with them have been awesome.
As far as clutch fan vs electric, I suppose this question depends on your usage. Clutch fans are very reliable, I have never personally had one fail. Electric fans allow you a little more finite control, and are better if you will be at idle or low speeds for long periods of time.
There are some radiator upgrades, I have stumbled across them from time to time, but I have never used any and could not offer any advice here.
As far as clutch fan vs electric, I suppose this question depends on your usage. Clutch fans are very reliable, I have never personally had one fail. Electric fans allow you a little more finite control, and are better if you will be at idle or low speeds for long periods of time.
There are some radiator upgrades, I have stumbled across them from time to time, but I have never used any and could not offer any advice here.
#35
Registered User
Thread Starter
What's left of my 22re is down at Autospec... Head was totaly cracked and had been milled too many times. The rust was too deep into the block si Phan suggested another one--I'm not gonna half ass it like the PO did.
Gonna go down and shoot pics when he builds it!
Gonna go down and shoot pics when he builds it!
#37
YotaTech Milestone-Two Millionth Post
make that bigger than a thumbnail....this ain't small stuff anymore........this is the good stuff now.....i want full page.....full screen YOTA PRON.
#39
YotaTech Milestone-Two Millionth Post