Slipping out of 3rd gear . . . .
#1
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Nashville
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Slipping out of 3rd gear . . . .
So my truck is a 1993, 22RE, 5 speed, 2wd, reg cab stripper. 157k miles on it, pretty beat up, but runs great.
So my problem is that the trans tends to slip out of 3rd gear. It engages into 3rd with no problem, but if you have very light or no throttle it will slip into netrual. It usually stays in gear if you have it past 1/3rd throttle. Right now my solution is to just hold my hand on the stick while its in 3rd, it stays in gear that way.
Like I said it shifts great, no grinding in any gear, doesn't whine or anything. The clutch is also on its way out, it tends to slip in 5th if you mat the throttle at 50-65mph, sometimes the clutch will slip a little bit in 4th as well. The clutch is also weird because the engagement point is almost at the top of the pedal, like a new clutch.
Anyways, could my worn clutch be related to my 3rd gear problem? I read in another thread that it could possibly be a bad clutch pilot bearing, not sure what that part is, but it sounds pretty easy to replace when I do the clutch.
I really don't want to do a trans rebuild on this truck, as it would probably cost more than the $650 I paid for it orignally.
So my problem is that the trans tends to slip out of 3rd gear. It engages into 3rd with no problem, but if you have very light or no throttle it will slip into netrual. It usually stays in gear if you have it past 1/3rd throttle. Right now my solution is to just hold my hand on the stick while its in 3rd, it stays in gear that way.
Like I said it shifts great, no grinding in any gear, doesn't whine or anything. The clutch is also on its way out, it tends to slip in 5th if you mat the throttle at 50-65mph, sometimes the clutch will slip a little bit in 4th as well. The clutch is also weird because the engagement point is almost at the top of the pedal, like a new clutch.
Anyways, could my worn clutch be related to my 3rd gear problem? I read in another thread that it could possibly be a bad clutch pilot bearing, not sure what that part is, but it sounds pretty easy to replace when I do the clutch.
I really don't want to do a trans rebuild on this truck, as it would probably cost more than the $650 I paid for it orignally.
#2
My transmission started doing the same thing at about 150,000 miles. I got one of these and that fixed the problem:
http://www.marlincrawler.com/transmi...ver-ball-seats
The factory one is made of rubber and crumbles over time.
http://www.marlincrawler.com/transmi...ver-ball-seats
The factory one is made of rubber and crumbles over time.
#5
Registered User
i think mine needs to be replaced as well, my shifter is super sloppy and have trouble getting it in 4th.
if you have a body lift try flipping your shifter boot upside down so its not not pulling on the shifter
if you have a body lift try flipping your shifter boot upside down so its not not pulling on the shifter
#6
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Nashville
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2wd man
Glad to see this isn't going to be a major ordeal like rebuilding the transmission. Figured it was something stupid and rubber that was worn out. I'm kind of new to manual trannies, do you have to drop the trans to change the clutch? I'm thinking I'll just replace that part when I change the clutch.
#7
Registered User
the trans does have to come out to change the clutch. i would probably go ahead and change the shifter bushings before doing the clutch the trans does not need to come out to change the bushings and then that way you can be sure that is in fact your problem, then if it turns out to not be the problem your not pulling the trans twice. the bushing could be changed out within probably 30 min at the most.
Trending Topics
#8
So those Marlin Crawler bushings actually rotate while you're shifting gears? I did not realize this until I read the description on their site just now. I thought it just sat in the same spot.
I have been having trouble getting into second gear sometimes. Usually it goes in really easy, but every once in a while I really have to pull hard on the shift lever or I'll end up grinding the gear.
I don't think I greased the sides and bottom of the bushing when I put it in, which you'd think would be important if the thing needs to rotate. So I'm wondering if it might be worthwhile to take mine out and grease it up a little better.
I have been having trouble getting into second gear sometimes. Usually it goes in really easy, but every once in a while I really have to pull hard on the shift lever or I'll end up grinding the gear.
I don't think I greased the sides and bottom of the bushing when I put it in, which you'd think would be important if the thing needs to rotate. So I'm wondering if it might be worthwhile to take mine out and grease it up a little better.
Last edited by peckinpah; 02-09-2011 at 05:12 AM.
#9
Registered User
The marlin bushing rotates in to place, it doesn't rotate once it's installed and functioning. The original bushing just got smushed in to place and nothing really held it there, the upgraded marlin bushing is threaded and so it stays put.
#10
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Nashville
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Figured out that if I give it a little bit more of a "firm hand" shifting into 3rd it will stay put. After modfying my shifting style the problem has gone away.
Still waiting on the bushing, still plan on changing it since I already bought the part. I'm sure it will shift a lot nicer once I put that thing in there as well.
Still waiting on the bushing, still plan on changing it since I already bought the part. I'm sure it will shift a lot nicer once I put that thing in there as well.
#11
Registered User
Our Heavy Duty Shift Seats and Sockets are a great way to upgrade stock components (they don't last nearly as long). I don't need to do much talking to express how cool these things are, honestly they make a night-and-day difference. Please take a look at the video on our installation page located at http://www.marlincrawler.com/tech/gu...t-installation to see how cool they are!
Aron9000,
Remember that it could be something else, like interference between the shifter boot and handle, or even the floorboard if your body or transfer case mounts have shifted. Also worn out engine mounts -- especially the driver's side -- can cause the drivetrain to move enough causing contact between the cab and the shifter. These issues are all worthwhile cases to inspect.
The simplest method would be to remove the cabin interior floor shift boot (not the small handle boot) and determine if the handle is coming anywhere near the body at all.
Moreover, an even worse case could be a badly worn out transmission center bearing plate. Through many miles of use, the center plate will begin to warp and yield to the constant pressure (thrust/axial loads) (because the gears feature a helical cut). When this happens, the main shaft is able to move forward or reward in relation to the housings. Keeping in mind that the shift forks are held in place by the housings, when the shaft moves towards or away from the shift fork, the gear is self-disengaged without any user input. So this could also cause your transmission to fall out of gear and unfortunately there is no way to remedy this short of replacing parts in your transmission.
Hopefully it is something simple such as boot-to-handle interference. Please let us know.
I wrote the description for our bushings and am always looking for ways to improve usability. Would you mind explaining what description caused this confusion? I would greatly appreciate your feedback!! Thank you very much in advance!
Regards,
BigMike
Aron9000,
Remember that it could be something else, like interference between the shifter boot and handle, or even the floorboard if your body or transfer case mounts have shifted. Also worn out engine mounts -- especially the driver's side -- can cause the drivetrain to move enough causing contact between the cab and the shifter. These issues are all worthwhile cases to inspect.
The simplest method would be to remove the cabin interior floor shift boot (not the small handle boot) and determine if the handle is coming anywhere near the body at all.
Moreover, an even worse case could be a badly worn out transmission center bearing plate. Through many miles of use, the center plate will begin to warp and yield to the constant pressure (thrust/axial loads) (because the gears feature a helical cut). When this happens, the main shaft is able to move forward or reward in relation to the housings. Keeping in mind that the shift forks are held in place by the housings, when the shaft moves towards or away from the shift fork, the gear is self-disengaged without any user input. So this could also cause your transmission to fall out of gear and unfortunately there is no way to remedy this short of replacing parts in your transmission.
Hopefully it is something simple such as boot-to-handle interference. Please let us know.
Regards,
BigMike
#12
It was this line that threw me off:
I interpreted this sentence to mean that the bushing rotates during gear shifts, rather than the intended meaning that refers to the rotation that occurs during installation.
I tend to read too fast and misinterpret sentences a lot. Bad habit of mine.
Hey, do you guys have any reasonably-priced 2WD street-type rear bumpers over there? I'm looking for one to replace the one that some drunk slammed into while I was sitting at a drive-up ATM. I don't care if it's used or not.
Instead of squeezing the seat into place, the groves on each side allow ours to rotate into position.
I tend to read too fast and misinterpret sentences a lot. Bad habit of mine.
Hey, do you guys have any reasonably-priced 2WD street-type rear bumpers over there? I'm looking for one to replace the one that some drunk slammed into while I was sitting at a drive-up ATM. I don't care if it's used or not.
Last edited by peckinpah; 03-07-2011 at 02:15 PM.
#13
Registered User
Regards,
BigMike
#15
Registered User
If you recently ordered it, then you are welcome to return it with a small restocking fee as per our Terms Page.
Nevertheless, a more precise shifter will not cause you to miss gears. It sounds like you'll need more than just a bandage to remedy your transmission issue.
Good luck with everything. Regards,
BigMike
Nevertheless, a more precise shifter will not cause you to miss gears. It sounds like you'll need more than just a bandage to remedy your transmission issue.
Good luck with everything. Regards,
BigMike
#16
Registered User
#17
Registered User
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
FS[PacSouthWest]: 2- 8"3rd members:4.88 ratchet lockers,new setup kit, rear axle rebuild kit,diff armor
jerusry
Axles - Suspensions - Tires - Wheels
1
10-19-2015 05:28 PM
justdifferentials
Just Differentials
1
08-15-2015 05:25 PM
Shaun Crystal Gomban
Pre 84 Trucks
5
07-30-2015 10:13 PM