Fresh Tech
#21
Contributing Member
Join Date: May 2002
Location: NY
Posts: 861
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Andrey
This is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard. Where exactly are you getting this information from?
-- Andrey
This is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard. Where exactly are you getting this information from?
-- Andrey
http://www.straightdope.com/mailbag/mradiomileage.html
Last edited by jalaber; 05-05-2003 at 11:47 AM.
#23
Banned
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Colorado Springs
Posts: 2,617
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Andrey
This is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard. Where exactly are you getting this information from?
-- Andrey
This is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard. Where exactly are you getting this information from?
-- Andrey
Cars with DRLs get lower insurance rates. If your insurer finds out they are disabled they may want to charge you more.
I turn on my headlights on 2 lane highways during the day to be as visible as possible. Its the same reason I choose bright yellow to paint my front bumper. Driving a brown truck simetimes makes you less visible.
#24
Originally posted by Andrey
And for those people who for some reason don't want DRL, all it takes is just a gentle pull of emergency break, and DRL won't come on until the break is released.
-- Andrey
And for those people who for some reason don't want DRL, all it takes is just a gentle pull of emergency break, and DRL won't come on until the break is released.
-- Andrey
#25
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Arizona
Posts: 1,009
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by jx94148
I guess it considers the extra resistance from the alternator a hinderance to fuel economy. The more current you use, the more force it takes to turn the alternator. Similar to what happens when your A/C compressor kicks on but its constant. The extra fuel used is marginal, maybe on par with a 5 MPH headwind.
I guess it considers the extra resistance from the alternator a hinderance to fuel economy. The more current you use, the more force it takes to turn the alternator. Similar to what happens when your A/C compressor kicks on but its constant. The extra fuel used is marginal, maybe on par with a 5 MPH headwind.
#26
Registered User
Andrey,
Don't know if you even notice it but the more acc.. you run the more load you put on your engine reducing milage. Nextime you are driving along at a steady pace switch on your climate control fan up to full speed w/o AC on. You can feel a noticable drag on your motor, why is this so?? it's only an electric motor in your heater fan. The fan motor at high speed is pulling a significant amount of amps which causes a system drain and makes the alt. work harder. Your radio (stock) and turn signals do not pull enough amps to effect your milage. High amperage/wattage items such as Headlights, heater fans, high power stereo amps do effect gas milage even if it is small. Put an "amp clamp" on your battery and turn things on one at a time and watch the amps go up, and remember "Nothing in life is free" and that includes gas milage every little bit helps.
Don't know if you even notice it but the more acc.. you run the more load you put on your engine reducing milage. Nextime you are driving along at a steady pace switch on your climate control fan up to full speed w/o AC on. You can feel a noticable drag on your motor, why is this so?? it's only an electric motor in your heater fan. The fan motor at high speed is pulling a significant amount of amps which causes a system drain and makes the alt. work harder. Your radio (stock) and turn signals do not pull enough amps to effect your milage. High amperage/wattage items such as Headlights, heater fans, high power stereo amps do effect gas milage even if it is small. Put an "amp clamp" on your battery and turn things on one at a time and watch the amps go up, and remember "Nothing in life is free" and that includes gas milage every little bit helps.
#27
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Arizona
Posts: 1,009
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by PirateFins
Andrey,
Don't know if you even notice it but the more acc.. you run the more load you put on your engine reducing milage. Nextime you are driving along at a steady pace switch on your climate control fan up to full speed w/o AC on. You can feel a noticable drag on your motor, why is this so?? it's only an electric motor in your heater fan. The fan motor at high speed is pulling a significant amount of amps which causes a system drain and makes the alt. work harder. Your radio (stock) and turn signals do not pull enough amps to effect your milage. High amperage/wattage items such as Headlights, heater fans, high power stereo amps do effect gas milage even if it is small. Put an "amp clamp" on your battery and turn things on one at a time and watch the amps go up, and remember "Nothing in life is free" and that includes gas milage every little bit helps.
Andrey,
Don't know if you even notice it but the more acc.. you run the more load you put on your engine reducing milage. Nextime you are driving along at a steady pace switch on your climate control fan up to full speed w/o AC on. You can feel a noticable drag on your motor, why is this so?? it's only an electric motor in your heater fan. The fan motor at high speed is pulling a significant amount of amps which causes a system drain and makes the alt. work harder. Your radio (stock) and turn signals do not pull enough amps to effect your milage. High amperage/wattage items such as Headlights, heater fans, high power stereo amps do effect gas milage even if it is small. Put an "amp clamp" on your battery and turn things on one at a time and watch the amps go up, and remember "Nothing in life is free" and that includes gas milage every little bit helps.
There are many many other things in life which affect gas mileage, such as frequent stops and go, using accelerator pedal too often, etc... But the difference with accessories is really probably 0.01-0.03%. And personally, I would rather enjoy my ride with nice music, cool interior and pleasant looks when saving 0.01% on gas. Heck, if I can afford $35K vehicle, I don't believe $0.05 is going to put a hole in my wallet
-- Andrey
#28
Originally posted by Andrey
This all sounds good in theory, but in real life I don't notice any loss of power with either AC on or off in my 4Runner, which has 3.4L engine.
This all sounds good in theory, but in real life I don't notice any loss of power with either AC on or off in my 4Runner, which has 3.4L engine.
#29
Registered User
I think you guys are getting jumbled up on your definition of "power".
The 10-15% loss is in terms of horsepower when the A/C compressor is engaged. I think other folks here are talking about electrical power because of the additional load on the alternator with the cabin fan motor kicked up.
fwiw, I too lose power with the A/C engaged, I have in all the cars I've owned. That compressor pump puts a real drag on an engine.
The 10-15% loss is in terms of horsepower when the A/C compressor is engaged. I think other folks here are talking about electrical power because of the additional load on the alternator with the cabin fan motor kicked up.
fwiw, I too lose power with the A/C engaged, I have in all the cars I've owned. That compressor pump puts a real drag on an engine.
#30
Registered User
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Duvall, WA
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I heard a crazy statistic like if all cars had DRL's that there would be 14,000,000 more gallons of gas used every hear or some insane number like that... don't know how true it is.
Last edited by Tatsuo; 05-05-2003 at 10:32 PM.
#31
Contributing Member
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Wandering around Phoenix
Posts: 6,033
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
If anybody's interested, I did a quick, rough calculation to figure out how much DRL cost per year.
190hp=141700watts
DRL @20watts each=40watts (guess)
40w/141700w=0.00028 so DRL use 0.028% of the engines power.
At $30 to fill up a tank-- $30x0.00028=$0.008
Fill up an average of once per week $0.008x52weeks=$0.44
44 cents for you 3rd gens. This does not take into account losses in the alternator and other electrical losses.
Spread out across the country this could be significant.
So everybody is correct, DRL lower mileage, but not significantly to the individual.
Steve
190hp=141700watts
DRL @20watts each=40watts (guess)
40w/141700w=0.00028 so DRL use 0.028% of the engines power.
At $30 to fill up a tank-- $30x0.00028=$0.008
Fill up an average of once per week $0.008x52weeks=$0.44
44 cents for you 3rd gens. This does not take into account losses in the alternator and other electrical losses.
Spread out across the country this could be significant.
So everybody is correct, DRL lower mileage, but not significantly to the individual.
Steve
#34
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Columbia, SC
Posts: 545
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One little trick!
Well... if you don't want to do any wire-snipping, there IS a simple alternative. I noticed one day that if your e-brake is pulled up even one click BEFORE you start the engine, the DRL's don't come on! One click doesn't physically engage the emergency brakes on on my 4Runner, so there's no rubbing, but electronically, the computer thinks they are engaged, and it's good if you want to sneak up on someone, with the engine off anyways of course. With the key in and the engine on, all you have to do is let off the e-brake and voila! One come the lights! Just make sure your key is in position 1 (right after inserting it) or not in the ignition at all when you pull your e-brake 1 click, and if you do rub don't keep this doing this. You can let it off at any time, engine on or off, key in or out. I guess it's the best of both worlds.
Zach
Zach
#35
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Juneau, Alaska
Posts: 991
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thats the way it is in my dads Chevy pick up. We sit in line at a public duck hunting place, and were blinding all the guys in front of us trying to sleep when we would turn on the rig to warm up the cab till we found that out a couple years ago.
I personally would use that feature than mess with the wiring of a new rig. I drive an 87 Runner so its all fair game.
Just my .02
I personally would use that feature than mess with the wiring of a new rig. I drive an 87 Runner so its all fair game.
Just my .02
#37
Contributing Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Fountain Valley, CA (so cali)
Posts: 1,997
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Corey
What you can do is also wire in a toggle.
Spilce it inline with that wire.
Put the switch up near you on the dash or underneath.
That way when you want the DRLs, no problemo
What you can do is also wire in a toggle.
Spilce it inline with that wire.
Put the switch up near you on the dash or underneath.
That way when you want the DRLs, no problemo
#39
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 52
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
DRLs are a bit dimmer than regular lights, and much less so than the brights. I have aftermarket headlights installed (bright!), so I put my light switch in the parking light position at night. It seems like I have three degrees of lights hehe (DRLs, normal, brights). About earlier posts...the alternator is never more "difficult" to turn for the engine, whatever the load. It puts out what it puts out. The A/C compressor is a load on the motor when the compressor clutch is engaged, not the fan for the interior.
#40
Contributing Member
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Wandering around Phoenix
Posts: 6,033
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally posted by heliax
About earlier posts...the alternator is never more "difficult" to turn for the engine, whatever the load. It puts out what it puts out.
About earlier posts...the alternator is never more "difficult" to turn for the engine, whatever the load. It puts out what it puts out.
It's like when you put a sudden electrical load on a generator, the engine slows down for a second before it can compensate. Why do you think it takes such a huge energy source like nuclear power or a hydroelectric dam to turn the generators? If the load is just there then you can just have a guy on a bicycle turn the generators.
Another example is when I use my signals on my corolla. Whenever I turn them on, my engine RPMs drop slightly everytime they blink.
Steve