Clutch questions that may sound silly....
#1
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Port Townsend, WA, USA
Posts: 74
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Clutch questions that may sound silly....
I know the basics of driving with a manual transmission, or at least I think I do (I am at least funtional because I drive all round town in one). My questions regard two things.
1. Is it correct procedure to gear down and let the clutch out and let the engine compression slow you when coming to a stop or slowing down? I have always done this but it seems to me that would wear on the clutch.
2. What is the exact specific definition of riding the clutch?
1. Is it correct procedure to gear down and let the clutch out and let the engine compression slow you when coming to a stop or slowing down? I have always done this but it seems to me that would wear on the clutch.
2. What is the exact specific definition of riding the clutch?
#2
Contributing Member
Re: Clutch questions that may sound silly....
Originally posted by markjs
I know the basics of driving with a manual transmission, or at least I think I do (I am at least funtional because I drive all round town in one). My questions regard two things.
1. Is it correct procedure to gear down and let the clutch out and let the engine compression slow you when coming to a stop or slowing down? I have always done this but it seems to me that would wear on the clutch.
2. What is the exact specific definition of riding the clutch?
I know the basics of driving with a manual transmission, or at least I think I do (I am at least funtional because I drive all round town in one). My questions regard two things.
1. Is it correct procedure to gear down and let the clutch out and let the engine compression slow you when coming to a stop or slowing down? I have always done this but it seems to me that would wear on the clutch.
2. What is the exact specific definition of riding the clutch?
2) Riding the clutch is when you allow the clutch to engage just enuf to hold your position (like on a hill instead of using the brakes). This is not proper technique but many people do it anyway. Totally up to you.
#4
Contributing Member
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Albuquerque, NM
Posts: 2,549
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
1) It is ok to let the engine slow you down.....it will only wear on the engine and has no effect on the clutch at all.
However, when my clutch went out I did ALOT of research to find the best clutch for my application. I spoke to just about every major performance clutch company in the US about them. Every person who actually builds clutches told me that down shifting is just about the worst thing you can do to your clutch short of actually riding it.
You should come to a stop with your brakes while holding the clutch in.
Brakes are a lot cheaper and easier to replace!
#5
Contributing Member
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Greenville, South Carolina
Posts: 1,736
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Albuquerque Jim
You should come to a stop with your brakes while holding the clutch in.
Brakes are a lot cheaper and easier to replace!
You should come to a stop with your brakes while holding the clutch in.
Brakes are a lot cheaper and easier to replace!
#6
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Dallas, TX
Posts: 221
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#1 - It is OK to use engine compression to assist you in coming to a complete stop, however, it is correct that this will cause premature wear on the clutch. In addition, it will cause your gas mileage to be less than optimal, and will send more pollutants out of your exhaust (The amount of gas you burn will be increased by the higher RPMs of your engine. Even though you're not accelerating, the injectors are still pumping that gas into the cylinders). However, there are times, primarily when descending steep and/or lengthy hills, that you don't want to use the brakes to slow down as brake 'fade' can dramatically reduce your ability to stop (and sometimes completely take it away). These are the times when you would want to use engine compression to aid your vehicle in slowing down.
#2 - "Riding the clutch" is a term that means that you are applying slight pressure to the clutch during normal driving when the clutch should be fully engaged. There are some who ride the clutch really bad, having their foot rest on top of the clutch pedal nearly all the time; others are guilty of it for just a second or two as they are releasing the clutch (ie they keep their foot on the pedal just a little bit too long).
From a safety standpoint, you should not be stopped with the clutch pedal pressed to the floor and the shifter in a gear. The reason is that if someone rear-ends you, your foot will probably come off the clutch pedal placing the car in gear, and then you will probably rear-end the guy in front of you.
Personally, when approaching a stop light I shift into neutral, take my foot of the clutch pedal, and use the brake to slow down. Then if the light turns green before I get to it I am able to select instantly whichever gear I need to get into. Additionally, since I am coasting in neutral, engine RPMs go to idle, reducing the amount of gas I am burning.
The downside is that coasting in neutral like that is illegal in some places. I'm not sure why, but I would assume that it is because you are not able to take emergency evasive manuevers if something (or someone) is in your way.
~Bill
#2 - "Riding the clutch" is a term that means that you are applying slight pressure to the clutch during normal driving when the clutch should be fully engaged. There are some who ride the clutch really bad, having their foot rest on top of the clutch pedal nearly all the time; others are guilty of it for just a second or two as they are releasing the clutch (ie they keep their foot on the pedal just a little bit too long).
From a safety standpoint, you should not be stopped with the clutch pedal pressed to the floor and the shifter in a gear. The reason is that if someone rear-ends you, your foot will probably come off the clutch pedal placing the car in gear, and then you will probably rear-end the guy in front of you.
Personally, when approaching a stop light I shift into neutral, take my foot of the clutch pedal, and use the brake to slow down. Then if the light turns green before I get to it I am able to select instantly whichever gear I need to get into. Additionally, since I am coasting in neutral, engine RPMs go to idle, reducing the amount of gas I am burning.
The downside is that coasting in neutral like that is illegal in some places. I'm not sure why, but I would assume that it is because you are not able to take emergency evasive manuevers if something (or someone) is in your way.
~Bill
#7
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 20
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I do something a little weird...
Stoplight: Clutch goes in, Brakes are hit and gear is moved 2 or 3 gears down....but never engaged.
I keep it like that (not in neutral!) in case I need to perform a quick escape/maneuver/etc.
I'd rather replace brake pads than my clutch. Downshifting *will* cause more wear and tear.
Braking but going through the motions of downshifting without engaging the clutch has saved my butt a few times.
-Leaf
Stoplight: Clutch goes in, Brakes are hit and gear is moved 2 or 3 gears down....but never engaged.
I keep it like that (not in neutral!) in case I need to perform a quick escape/maneuver/etc.
I'd rather replace brake pads than my clutch. Downshifting *will* cause more wear and tear.
Braking but going through the motions of downshifting without engaging the clutch has saved my butt a few times.
-Leaf
Trending Topics
#8
Registered User
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Portland, Oregon
Posts: 1,537
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I want my vehicle in gear just prior to a few feet of stopping. If your vehicle is in gear and you slow down and you need to speed up quickly then your response time will much better than somone who had to depress the clutch peddle and put in gear and rev up the engine. (Densive driving 101)
The same goes with down shifting to slow the vehicle down in traffic. It allows the option to speed quickly if the situation demands it.
I often down shift with heavy loads on a trailer to save the brakes when driving on the highway. Heck, I even double clutch.
Double clutching: To depress the clutch peddle to allow the gear shift to be moved to nuetral, release the clutch while the gear is in neutral, and ,again, depress the clutch peddle to allow the gear shift to go into the next gear.
Driving a manual transmission isn't easy or everyone would have one. I have driven semi's and trailers for over 5 years including 13 and 10 speed transmissions. Each vehicle, transmission and engine are different. Take the time to find what is best for your combo. Clutches and brakes are costly to replace but, major body work or a hospital stay could be more.
Food for thought.
The same goes with down shifting to slow the vehicle down in traffic. It allows the option to speed quickly if the situation demands it.
I often down shift with heavy loads on a trailer to save the brakes when driving on the highway. Heck, I even double clutch.
Double clutching: To depress the clutch peddle to allow the gear shift to be moved to nuetral, release the clutch while the gear is in neutral, and ,again, depress the clutch peddle to allow the gear shift to go into the next gear.
Driving a manual transmission isn't easy or everyone would have one. I have driven semi's and trailers for over 5 years including 13 and 10 speed transmissions. Each vehicle, transmission and engine are different. Take the time to find what is best for your combo. Clutches and brakes are costly to replace but, major body work or a hospital stay could be more.
Food for thought.
#9
Registered User
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Parker, Colorado
Posts: 1,564
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I only downshift when coming to a stop at about 20-25mph, when engine RPMS are going to be low. My engine also sometimes stutters and that's when I know its time to down shift (if you've ever gone down to 15-20mph in 4th gear).
I keep the car in neutral, clutch out at lights, but I don't stick it in neutral until about 5mph, any evasive maneuver at this speed is going to just be braking.
I keep the car in neutral, clutch out at lights, but I don't stick it in neutral until about 5mph, any evasive maneuver at this speed is going to just be braking.
#11
Registered User
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Parker, Colorado
Posts: 1,564
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was thinking that earlier too, I almost always ride it in reverse, cuz I don't want to back up too quickly.
Also, in first gear, when I am going into my parking spot at home. Its this tiny wedge of rocks, and its up a slope, so I have to give it gas, but not enough to spin the tires, and not to the point I am crashing it into the corner of the garage.
Also, in first gear, when I am going into my parking spot at home. Its this tiny wedge of rocks, and its up a slope, so I have to give it gas, but not enough to spin the tires, and not to the point I am crashing it into the corner of the garage.
#12
Contributing Member
You guys haven't driven in snow much, have you? I have much better control coming up to a stop by downshifting and not touching the brakes at all. No brakes = no skidding. Try it some time. FWIW, in Colorado, it is illegal to be moving and not in gear. Not something they can enforce, but soemthing to think about.
Last edited by toy283; 01-07-2004 at 06:12 PM.
#13
Registered User
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Parker, Colorado
Posts: 1,564
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes it is illegal to not be in gear in colorado. I believe it is because of winter months, and the chance of hitting ice. If you have no power to the wheels to recover from a skid, its a bad thing. But, I never take it out of gear when I'm rolling around in the slick stuff anywho.
I actually prefer braking in the snow. Sometimes I will downshift, but I've started to fishtail from downshifting. Definately gotta know the speed (and resulting RPMs) when you downshift, I think thats why I fishtailed, went from 3rd to 2nd at 28mph, too high of RPMs, or maybe I let the clutch out too quick... Probably the latter
I actually prefer braking in the snow. Sometimes I will downshift, but I've started to fishtail from downshifting. Definately gotta know the speed (and resulting RPMs) when you downshift, I think thats why I fishtailed, went from 3rd to 2nd at 28mph, too high of RPMs, or maybe I let the clutch out too quick... Probably the latter
#15
Banned
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: White Mountains, Arizona (Yes it does snow in AZ)
Posts: 553
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I drive in snow here and toy283 is correct... come on people "the clutch is your friend". Use it whenever. I get about 150k on my clutches so far using it often to help slow my ride.
#16
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Granbury, Tx.
Posts: 64
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
down shift
Here is your answer. The major problem that most people do not know is that when you use your clutch to slow down your not hurting the clutch but your stretching your timeing chain, you are reversing the affect of accelleration on the chain and the force from bringing the vehicle to such a drop in rpm with the full force decelleration transfering from the wheels to the tranny through the clutch, you tend to forget that it dosn't stop there! The engine feels that pressure also and it ends up at the timing chain. Trust me brakes are alot cheaper, just go and ask any old timer thats worked for toyota and they'll tell you the same!
#19
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: british columbia
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
clutch vs brakes
I've got a buddy that races a Subaru WRX in autocross and teaches a peformance driving school and they teach that the clutch style braking only yields approx. 10-15% better braking. So if it's not an emergency, save your clutch and use your brakes.